A video I happened to watch of Mr. Gowtham, an agriculturist
made me think twice about us, our society and our country as a whole. When Mr.
Gowtham and his friends were offered a salary of Rs. two lakh per month, they
quit their job. The decision would ridicule many of us at first. But the
reason he gave for this was indeed thought provoking. He explained how the glitters of corporate
life make (force) an individual to live in luxury that is beyond necessity.
Once he gets a salary hike he makes up his mind to invest in a house or a car
for which he takes a loan with EMI. This gets him indebted to pay the EMI
amount for the next ten years or so. This payment cannot be stopped (unless he
wants to fall in deep trouble) or the amount reduced, even if there is a
recession or any other calamity or if he loses his job. The banks will show no
mercy on him. Ultimately, the individual is trapped in the future for what may
seem luxurious and affordable today.
Now that many of us including myself belong to the
corporate world, this is great message for us. Mr. Gowtham is an agriculturist
today, earning rupees seventy-five thousand per month!
I want to discuss another issue here which I’d like
to link with Mr. Gowtham’s views later. This is about our great loyal politicians
who allowed Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in India. Wal-Mart has opened their
distribution network in Chennai. As per the rules and regulations, they have
not opened any store in India but have opened a distribution center through
which they buy materials on bulk and supply to the Kirana stores, departmental
stores, etc. Thus, Wal-Mart has not opened one shop, but thousands of shops
that are indirectly owned by Wal-Mart at the back end (as supplier). This shows
that, once all the FDI issues have settled down Wal-Mart can increase the rates
to customers which being Kirana stores and other small stores. This would lead
to their closing down gradually due to lack of margin. Finally, in the long run when most of the
small shops are closed down due to affordability issues, Wal-Mart may give its
helping hand to India by opening stores where customers can afford goods at a
cheaper price, which our mom and pop shops couldn’t do. And we in turn would
start praising Wal-Mart.
But the bottom
line is that this is going to be a big blow to the farmers and the mom and pop
shop-walas in the long run. Just looking at the statistics or having a bird’s
eye view of all this will not help in understanding their sufferings (and in
turn ours too) practically. Politicians and
big guys like Wal-Mart play using that very trump card and sustain their
business.
Ultimately, they are shaking the backbone of India!
Now, linking both the news, I want to tell you that
there are small steps that we ourselves can take that can impact our neighborhoods atleast
marginally if not drastically.
Let me share something that I’ve started as my
small step to do what I can against this. Since the last few days, I have
stopped consuming cool drinks such as cola. Though I still consume food from
KFC, Domino’s et cetera, I have begun to realize the fact that if once India
was ruled by foreigners, it’s is very well going to happen again in a different
way. So, I consume Indian products whenever I can thus starting off with soft
drinks. I hope my measures convince my friends to start doing their part as
well, in whatever small ways they can. If we use only Indian products, our
money shall get cycled only in our country thereby encouraging our people to
start up more ventures and not be afraid of the so-called “foreign brands”. I’m
sure if some things turn out positive, this can bring up a lot of Indian brands
to the International market and boost our export which in turn improve our
economy greatly.
For example, Basics is
a Tamil Nadu (Indian) apparel brand and Chick King is a Kerala (Indian) brand.
We need not go back to Khadi clothes, but we still could prove a strong
competition to the foreign brands with our very own Indian brands.
So, combining all the
above facts, when Wal-Mart start attacking the farmers, a few farmers like Mr.
Gowtham would not be making deals with Wal-Mart, they would have their own
supply chain and sell their products through some front end partners (
departmental/kirana stores). So when I change myself in the way I expressed
above, I won’t be buying from the supply chain of Wal-Mart and will support
people like Mr. Gowtham. If this can be virally spread and people start
realizing the same, our purpose is achieved for which we are going against FDI
in India and therefore destroy the monopoly conditions!
If you want a change, you have to be the change. Let
us all do our parts in making India a better place to live in.
Readers, please share in your views about this. I
apologize for anything that I might have stated wrongly, please feel free to
tell me what you think! Thank you for taking the time and reading this.
I also include my Tamil poetry ( with English translation)about
my deep-felt thoughts regarding this.
Irandam Adhyayam
(The Second Chapter)
Annai madiyil sombal murikka
(Woke up in my mother's
lap)
Ayyan kaiyil nadai pazhagi
(Learned to walk from my
father's hands)
Aaradi annan er pidikka
(With my brothers working
in the agriultural fields )
Amarnthu undome kootu kudumbamaga
(We sat and had our food
as a joint family)
Paruthi mudhal pattu varai
(From the name of cotton
to silk)
Aanmigam mudhal aruviyal varai
(From Theism to the new
world Science)
Paraikotti varaiyaruththu em
pattanandro.?
(Is it not
my ancestors who preached this to the world?)
Avan andaththin aathiyai
parthavanandro.?
(And is he not the one who
saw the origin of the Universe?)
Ulaga pothumarayum unnatha
kalacharamum
(The thirukkural and the
beautiful culture)
paraikoti paprisaliththu magilntha
paariyargal
(We are people who give
others what we have with a smile)
vazhvaliththu nattin valamaliththu
simmasanamiliththu
(The crowd which gave
life, treasures, wisdom and our throne)
adimaiyaga aasaikonda engal avalam
paarir.!
(And how fondly they are
willing to be a slave)
Pugalchiyin bothayayum bayaththin
Ukkiraththayum
(Both the addiction of
praising and the fear of pain)
Azhagai kattinai aatchiyayum
pidiththai
(U showed it beautifully
to whom u show it correspondingly)
Kambu kondu kaththi
kondu emmakkalai aandai
(U ruled my people with slavery,
with pain)
Mudiyatha
Tharunangalil Pirithalum Soolchi kondai
(When u failed at that, you
used the divide and rule strategy)
Guninthu Valainthu Un
kalanigalin karaipadinthu - Nee Kulikaaya
(Beaten by U they fell in
the ground with your boots stains and to worm)
tham kaneerin anal
thanthu mandanare emmakkal
(They died giving the
warmth from their tears)
Piriththalum
ennaththirku ethirchollai parisalikka
(Unity is the antonym for
divide and rule it seems)
Vetrumayil otrumayai
vendrukatti karpithanare
(They won the game by
showing you the Unity in diversity)
kalnenja kayavargalin
tharkaliga parisam - inithey
(A temporary gift
given by the stone hearted fellows)
arangeriyathu
nalliravu nadagam andru - 1947
(They staged the midnight drama delightfully)
ariyamai ennum
aabaththaana aayuthamam - Immurayum
(A powerful weapon this
time called IGNORANCE - even this time)
adimayaga aasai konda
engal avalam paarir.!
(see! how fondly they are
willing to be a slave)
Itho indru irandam
aththiyayam - ithil
(And now we have this
chapter no.2 - In this)
adimai endru ariyamaye
ariyamaye vedikkaiyagum
(The comical fact is
that we are so ignorant of being slave)
unnum unavum uduthum
udayum kulirootum banamumai
(The food we eat, the
dress we wear, and the drinks which we have)
uchchi mudhal
ullankalvarai anaiththum anniyare.!
(From tip to toe
everything is a foreign brand)
Vyabaara kuri ennum
viyaththagu thanthiramam
(There we have this
magical word called BRAND)
India porulendral izhivaga
ennida vaikkumam
(Which makes us to
think very cheap if it is an Indian brand)
ennugira ennangalileye
nanjai kalanthuvittane
(He has mixed the
venom even in our thoughts)
tharam ennum sollil
tharayil mandiyida vaiththane.!
(With the one word
called quality he made us kneel down in the ground)
Iyarkayudan kalanthu
isaiyudan pinanithu
(The family which
Mixed with nature, mingled with music)
ilaneer parugi
inbutriruntha kudumbam
(And happily lived
with the taste of tender coconut)
vegamai thindru
vilambaraththil moozhgi - melliya vishamam
(Now started eating
fast, drowned in the advertisements)
athai inithe suvaikkum
kodumai kelir
(See the pathetic
situation of my people who are happily enjoying the taste of a slow poison)
Vizhihthukol nanbane.!
Purinthukol nanbane.!
(Wake up my friend...
Learn it my friend...)
Than nalam thedi un nalam
kedukkum - Anniya
(Forgetting about you
on the verge of making their money)
porulukku adaikalam kodukkum
kalaignargal venden
(We don't need these
artists who advertise these foreign brands)
kalkaasu kanchendralum
athu nam uzhavanukku pogattum.!
(Even if it is a penny
let it go to our farmer)
Oorin ellaivarai solluvom
ithai urakkacholluvom
(Let us tell it loudly
to the end of our place)
karuvakki uruvakki
kalainayaththudan merugetri
(Conceived, gave
birth, brought up and after beatifying your kid)
ayyan peyarai matri
vaiththal avamanamandro.?
(Is it not a shame on
u to keep your neighbor's initial?)
Athu nam natin
sabakkedandro.?
(Is it not a bane on
our country?)
Nallathor mudiveduppom
nattukor nanmai seivom
(Let us do something
good for the country)
Anniya muthaleedu nam
muthukelumbin kuraipadu - athai
(FDI is a wound in our
backbone ... so)
aaniverudan thagartheriya
ariyamayai thurappom
(We should uproot and
throw it away all together)
nammannil thenirukka
theinthu povanen mathubanam arunthida..!
(When there is honey
in our land why do you want to die for a glass of alcohol?)
Varadhu is..well, a person of strong opinions and values who weighs friendhsip a great deal more than many others would.He is a hardcore "marketing" person and a creative head as well! :)
ReplyDeleteWell written varadhu... u hav given lot of thought into it!!! The poem at the end of it is a nice little topping to a dessert well made!! Hats off!! :D
ReplyDeleteSorry for the responding to this entry so late, but I think I should be pointing out some of the facts I feel in this matter. First of all, I appreciate somebody coming out and giving out their stance on such two sided issue. From reading your article I take it that you are entirely against FDI in India.
ReplyDeleteFDI in retail means foreign direct investment in the Indian retail business. Now the retail business can be either a single brand retail business (like say one particular brand for example Gucci setting up its store in India) or multi brand retail (like Walmart, Carrefour). The hoopla is regarding the government's decision to allow FDI of 51% under multi brand retail.
Foreign players will bring in the necessary investment to upgrade the retail sector infrastructure across the country. Since their focus would be profit they would set up efficient supply chain management systems to ensure that product deliveries are on time. The emphasis would be on reduction in wastage of food items. This would bring down the food prices which have been a major cause of inflation in the country as well as a source of public dissent against the government.
1) The farmers would get a better price for their produce for two reasons. Foreign players would bring in the practice of contractual farming which would be beneficial for the farmers. It would also lead to the removal of the middle men which would provide additional revenue to the farmers (the retail chains would buy directly from the farmers).
2) Contractual farming would also mean improved and efficient farming practices as well as higher output and better prices. It would also generate employment opportunities in the wake of improved supply chains that would be setup to cater to these retail stores. It is mandated in the policy that 50% of any investment over a $100 million approx. would be in the backend infrastructure which would benefit by creating jobs as well as infrastructure for a developing country like India.
What I’ve provided above is only the pros of a conversation, but I would like to conclude saying:
1) It is true that on the basis of research FDI has showed us it’s possibility of a positive impact as well as its negativity drawback, but I would say that the government should promote FDI and it should also redesign the framework in order to lower down its negative impact on the local players.
2) The Government should encourage FDI on a slow pace depending on the products from one area to the other & product category-wise clauses should be developed.
3) In order to maintain the pace with the growing GDP, foreign investment is a must.
4) India needs monumental amounts of fund inflow to drive the investment in its infrastructure, a lack of which, is our main restriction in the country’s economic growth.
In short, FDI should be incorporated with strict feasible and mutually beneficial regulations because “Better Investment Climate” is the Need of the Hour.
P.S. Chicking group is a division of Al-Bayan Group of Companies UAE.
P.P.S. Most of the numerical data’s I have mentioned are poached from the “www”